That is the question. I’m lucky that there is a bulk food store right by my house – I love it there. But I have found that there are some items that just aren’t a good deal and since it is Frugal Food Friday I thought I would share them with you! So here are my top 5 items worth buying at the bulk food store and top 5 you are better off skipping!
Worth Buying
1. Flour – Depending on the quantity and type. I find that sometimes I need something like self rising flour and only a couple cups of it, the rest destined to sit on my shelf for months on end. This is when it’s a good idea to save some money and only get what you need. Want to try making rye bread? Or 12 grain? The bulk food store has many specialty flours including gluten free. It’s a good idea to pick them up here if you want to try something new, so you aren’t buying 10lbs of it the first time.
2. Spices – There is hardly ever a reason to need a value sized pack of a spice. It’s not fresh and by the time you use that much dried Thyme it will have lost most of its flavour. Buying in smaller quantities also keeps you engaged in your pantry so you know what you have on hand and what you are running low on. No nasty surprises when it comes time to do some baking!
3. Candy – I like buying little bits of candy or chocolate here because I have no self control. Once its in my house its in my mouth. So this way I can buy just a little bit. 3 or 4 little pieces that let me feel like I’ve had a treat but don’t result in me eating 3 candy bars. The trick here is to only purchase the little bit of candy you are going to eat. NO MORE. For me at least… there is no ‘saving for later’.
4. Oatmeal – Cheaper at the Bulk Barn than at the grocery store…
5. Sugar – Again I find it cheaper, unless there is a sale on sugar at the grocery store… which there happens to be around Thanksgiving and Christmas when everyone is baking.
Skip at the Bulk Store
1. Rice – It may not look expensive at only a few cents per hundred grams, but it adds up and is usually a nasty surprise. You are better off buying a bag of it at the grocery store. Unless it is some super specialized rice that you only need one cup of and are never going to use again. In that case buy only what you need.
2. Nuts – Again, pricey. They are expensive in grocery stores too, but this way you know exactly how much you are paying per container. When it is up to me to fill a bag I always get way more than I need in the first place and pay way too much. Best to take the mystery out and buy a container of nuts at a set price.
3. Dried Fruit – Do you know how much a pound of dried fruit is? Not as much as you think. Again I get overzealous when filling the bags and have had to return some items that I’ve gotten ready because of the shock of how much it came to when I was finished. I’m looking at you expensive dried blueberries. So you either need to be very careful about how much you are buying, or just get a set amount of dried fruit for a price you know up front from the grocery store.
4. Cake / Muffin Mixes – Anything you are getting here you can make with flour and a few other ingredients. The less variety of things you need to buy and the more you make from the staples you are already purchasing the lower your grocery bill.
5. Cereal – most times it is stale. Don’t bother, any cost savings are negated by the fact that you wont want to eat it in the first place.


11 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 26, 2010 at 9:56 am
Elisha Stam
I’m a huge Bulk Barn shopper, and I would back up everything you are saying. I find that nuts/ dried fruit are cheaper but that you just eat more if more is around ( ie you have a giant bag in your pantry).
Another steal is natural peanut butter. It’s the cheapest there by about $2/ 100g and it doesn’t separate as much.
Thanks for this post….
November 26, 2010 at 10:18 am
simplyfreshottawa
Good call on the peanut butter. Hubby eats about 1kg a week – loves the stuff, I’m going to have to look into this.
November 26, 2010 at 9:57 am
Erika Shea
Love this post! I was just at the Bulk Barn and nearly fell over when my seemingly reasonably sized bag of mixed nuts came to $22! I do love love love their prices on oatmeal though – especially being able to mixed rye, spelt and rolled oats (yummy) for way less than a bag if quaker at the grocery store.
Also – I totally second your approach to sweets buying!
November 26, 2010 at 10:20 am
simplyfreshottawa
I once had $18 worth of dried blueberries… I had to put it back. I hate doing that but there was no room in the budget for that much dried fruit. I can handle the price, just not the nasty surprise because it weighs more than I thought.
November 26, 2010 at 10:55 am
melodie
I totally agree! I have been known to faint at the final price of pine nuts while at the cash register at Bulk Barn. I quickly regained conscience and left the bag there. They are 1/2 price at Costco. I don’t have a membership but have dear friends who do. I also found that pasta are not worth it. They often are in sale at the grocery store and the price is better there, even for the unusual pasta.
November 26, 2010 at 11:56 am
simplyfreshottawa
I’ve found that with the pasta too! It adds up pretty quickly and it isn’t the cheapest option.
November 26, 2010 at 11:19 am
Ian
Costco for nuts.
I add walnuts to my oatmeal and dry roast a few pecans in a frying pan to toss into salads, and I think Costco is cheapest. That said, like many things Costco they only sell in a large volume format, so you want to only buy if it’s something you use on a regular or semi-regular basis.
Ian
November 26, 2010 at 11:55 am
simplyfreshottawa
I’m going to have to look into costco for nuts!
November 26, 2010 at 11:49 am
Pickles
Like you, I prefer buying from bulk bins, and like you I’ve also had some nasty surprises (a bag of pine nuts for $65!!!). Peanut butter is not only cheaper, but it has what it’s suppose to: peanuts. Sometimes the packaged products are better priced than a specialty store -possibly a dollar or more difference. One of the biggest perks: quality. It’s normally the same depending on the product.
November 26, 2010 at 11:57 am
simplyfreshottawa
$65?!?! Wow!
November 28, 2010 at 3:38 pm
Kim Meier
I just did my Christmas cookie ingredient shopping. Nuts are definitely cheapest at Costco. I made the mistake of buying almonds at Bulk Barn, because they were on sale and I thought the price was less than at Costco, but Costco’s bags are 1.3 kg. Right now, they have a good selection in Ontario: almonds, pecans, hazelnuts, sliced almonds, walnuts and pine nuts. I keep my nuts in the freezer and they keep well. Bulk barn is good for the selection of things that are harder to find. Personally I’ve found that oatmeal is less expensive at the grocery store.