One of the items on my bucket list was to find Ottawa’s Best…. something. I started out by attempting to find Ottawa’s best taco. That’s when I a) realized how many places do tacos in Ottawa; b) couldn’t decide on what qualified as ‘the best’ when it came to tacos, I had an amazing fusion taco, a fantabulous authentic taco and some great value meals… what was ‘the best’?? and c) saw another post about Ottawa’s best taco thus squashing my enthusiasm for the project.
So I picked myself up and dusted myself off and set out in search of Ottawa’s best brew. I sampled many but decided to compare apples to apples if at all possible and focus my search to Ale’s. Otherwise we’d be here a while as I tried beer after beer… hmmm…. maybe I should have gone ahead with that.
Anyway… I narrowed it down to three on my own and set up a blind taste test to get the opinions of my friends. Sampling a selection from Beaus, Kichisippi and Mill Street, the winner was…
Ta da!!!!!
The Millstreet Tankhouse Ale. They loved the flavour! That’s not to say they didn’t love all the other beers too… but when push comes to shove and they were forced to choose this is what the ‘panel’ came up with. As my friend Shaun pointed out, weather might have influenced some votes. It was a cooler night and that might have had some going for a bolder flavoured beer. If I had this taste test in the middle of summer a lighter ale might have fared better. I think we should try this again this summer… in the name of science.
What do you think?? What is your favorite local brew?
*** Updated ***
Ok… one of my readers got me on a wording technicality and Jeff, you are so totally right. He pointed out that Ottawa has dozens of great beers and beer styles so really this is Ottawa’s Best ALE. Not brew, beer or anything else. He also pointed out that Tankhouse isn’t brewed in Ottawa. But I decided that with the Ottawa Brew Pub in town I will let it slide and welcome all Mill Street products into our big happy Ottawa beer family. At least for this taste test.
I should also point out that this is just the opinion of a handful no need to get panties in a knot. Though I’m sure to one day have my own award show for great food and drink in Ottawa… that day is not yet here. But rest assured that when I do they will be based on personal preference as well… because hell… that’s what I’m all about.
*** Updated x2***
Alright kids, while I still totally stand by the results of my blind taste test. It really isn’t fair to the other beers. Tankhouse is really more of a Toronto expat so I can’t really call it Ottawa’s best anything. Sigh… guess I’m just going to have to try this again in a do over! But this time I’m going to do it right. A little more research BEFORE I start drinking the beers and writing posts. This calls for: ANOTHER TASTE TEST. Hmmm… was this all a part of my scheme to drink more beer?? No. I don’t plan that far ahead.
I may just be getting the hang of this ‘professionalism’ thing. Not likely.
Ok. So here is where I need your help. I can’t drink every Ottawa beer. I mean… I say I can but my doctor disagrees. Pfft. So what I need are suggestions on which Ottawa beer’s to try. Any style. Go nuts. What should I drink?? I’ll get a few people together, we’ll sample and get back to you with the results in a post I’m calling for the time being “Ottawa’s Best Brew 2: Electric Boogaloo”. Top 5 suggestions will be part of my second blind taste test.


18 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 23, 2012 at 9:46 am
Jennifer
I’m a fan of that Ambre de la Chaudiere at Mill Street.
April 23, 2012 at 9:51 am
Rigatoni
Clocktower Brown is the best beer produced in Otown…Kichesippi’s 1855 is a very, very close 2nd. Mill Street’s IPA is a much more superior beer to the ‘Tankhouse’
April 23, 2012 at 10:06 am
Andrew Craig
I love the Portage! It’s a great beer and it’s brewed here in Ottawa
April 23, 2012 at 10:24 am
simplyfreshottawa
Awesome choice!
April 23, 2012 at 10:39 am
Chris
I love Mill St. and I love their Tankhouse Ale.. but, it’s not brewed here in Ottawa, so not really an “Ottawa Brew.”
April 23, 2012 at 10:41 am
simplyfreshottawa
Good point Chris!
April 23, 2012 at 10:45 am
Chris
Still, I’m all for encouraging people to try different beers, so I’ll stop being a nit-picker.
April 23, 2012 at 10:55 am
simplyfreshottawa
No… you are right. I think this calls for: ANOTHER TASTE TEST. Hmmm… was this all a part of my scheme to drink more beer?? No. I don’t plan that far ahead. So dropping the limits of ‘ale only’ what Ottawa beer do I need to sample?? Top 5 suggestions will be part of my second blind taste test.
April 23, 2012 at 11:00 am
Chris
Broadhead’s Grindstone Amber is really, really good: http://www.broadheadbeer.com
April 23, 2012 at 11:02 am
Rigatoni
great idea…a true local taste test… call the Clocktower, they might be able to set you up with a Growler for your test, or even let you host it in their basement so you’re able to compare the others.
Please don’t let the name “Hog’s Back” fool you as it is NOT brewed in Otown but at the Cool facility in Brampton.
The Ashton Pub is now a brew pub as well, so a call out to them might be fair as well…
April 23, 2012 at 11:04 am
simplyfreshottawa
Great idea. Thanks!
April 23, 2012 at 11:09 am
Kelly Rusk
I do think you can still qualify Hog’s Back as an Ottawa brewer though:
“This is the number one question we get asked. The short answer is – we don’t have a brewery yet but we’re working on it! At this stage of the business, we brew our HogsBack Vintage Lager using our recipe under contract with another Ontario brewery where we carefully supervise the production of each batch. In the craft beer industry, this is a common approach especially for new beer companies. One of the reasons we chose to start this way was that it has allowed us to put the proper time and consideration into planning our own brewery in Ottawa. We want the HogsBack Brewery to be a must-visit destination, a place where Ontario’s finest beers are made and where you and your friends can meet to share a glass or two.
A “local” brewing company but no brewery? Absolutely! As you may already know, all four owners live in Ottawa, we developed the recipe for our Vintage Lager with an Ottawa brewer, our distribution facility is in the Ottawa area, we work with Ottawa suppliers wherever we can, our market focus is Ottawa, we took our name from Ottawa’s Hog’s Back Falls….well you get the picture! Our goal is to open the doors to the brewery in the next year, and you can be sure that we will put the same pride into our new home as we did into our Vintage Lager. “
April 23, 2012 at 11:02 am
Kelly Rusk
If you like Tankhouse then definitely Kichesippi 1855 would be the better contender. Also maybe Hog’s Back and the new brewery.. Broadhead?
http://www.hogsback.ca/home.htm
http://broadheadbeer.com/
Happy tasting~!
April 23, 2012 at 11:13 am
Rigatoni
Hogsback is NOT a local beer. There is NO brewery in Ottawa or surrounding area. The beer is produced in Brampton, Ontario at the Cool Beer Facility.
April 23, 2012 at 11:46 am
simplyfreshottawa
Actually they are brewing a beer of theirs (kilty bastard) at the Ashton Pub. http://klwatts.typepad.com/im-weird/2012/04/how-to-start-a-brewery.html
April 23, 2012 at 12:50 pm
pintinhand
Sorry – all my comments have been on Facebook up to this point. Hogsback is locally owned and currently contract brewed outside of Ottawa – which doesn’t mean they aren’t looking for a long-term local solution and yes they did just pair up with the Ashton Brewing Company to produce Kilty Bastard. I believe at some point they will be brewing in Ottawa – I’d even bet money on it. Sleeman’s is owned by Sapporo, Labatt by In-Bev and Molson by Coors – but do we still consider them Canadian companies? I NOW see the Top 5 suggestion comment – and ALE only (which would take the Vintage Lager out but leave Kilty Bastard in – saving other inevitable disagreements) When is the deadline for our submissions? Should we submit three each (top 3) to help you whittle it down to three? Would you like Randy and I to join you for this? lol
April 23, 2012 at 12:54 pm
simplyfreshottawa
YES!! You and Randy need to be there!!! This just got legit.
Oh… and suggest as many great beers (of any kind) that you like. In the end we’ll vote and pick the top 5.
April 23, 2012 at 9:30 pm
Holly
Broadhead beer is fantastic! The Dark Horse stout especially, but the Amber is also great if you’re looking for an ale.